Why China still needs a trade deal

Image of Beijing central business district skyline at night

China’s second-quarter GDP growth figure of 6.2% year-on-year appears to be the source of some market angst, not least because it represents the slowest rate of increase since 1992, which is as far back as Beijing’s records go.

It is possible to argue that such a rate of advance is pretty remarkable for what is the world’s second largest economy. If China were to maintain that growth rate for all of 2019, then its economy would, based on World Bank data, grow by $844 billion this year. That is more than the entire output of Saudi Arabia, the world’s eighteenth-largest economy.

And yet economists and financial markets alike seem concerned. The degree of worry among the latter can be easily measured by using the Shanghai Composite as a benchmark: the index trades no higher now than it did in January 2007.

“The degree of worry among the latter can be easily measured by using the Shanghai Composite as a benchmark: the index trades no higher now than it did in January 2007.”


Chinese equities are treading water again

Source: Refinitiv data.

The benchmark even stands some 10% below its April high, thanks in no small part to how $7.4 billion flowed out of Chinese equities in May. That was the biggest monthly outflow since June 2013, according to data from the Institute of International Finance.

Yet this bad news could be good news. The prevailing nerves about the economic outlook may persuade patient contrarians to think there is some value to be had, with Chinese equities trading on around 14 times forward earnings.

Economic jitters

All the same, three charts make it easy to see why economists and asset allocators are a bit nervous.

The first is the marked slowdown in Chinese export and import activity. Imports have fallen year-on-year five times in the last six months and in May exports grew just 0.3% year-on-year. The former may reflect domestic softness, the latter slower global growth but also the impact of the trade dispute with America, where there seems little sign of an immediate resolution despite the hopes raised by President Trump at June’s G20 meeting in Osaka.

Chinese import and export growth has slowed right down in 2019

Source: Refinitiv data, FRED – St. Louis Federal Reserve database

The second may be a spill-over from the trade slowdown. Chinese producer price inflation has slowed right down, raising fears that the country’s manufacturers may be sliding into some sort of supply-side glut or even a deflationary bust. Similar concerns did a huge amount of damage to the Shanghai Composite in 2015–16.

Producer prices may be sliding toward deflationary territory

Source: Refinitiv data, FRED – St. Louis Federal Reserve database

The third is car sales. China is trying to pivot away from making stuff for export and building bridges to nowhere (or at least homes where no-one lives) and towards consumption. A slide in the auto market suggests this plan may be hitting a speed bump with volumes set to fall for the second straight year.

“A slide in the auto market suggests that China’s plan to pivot away from manufacturing and exports and toward consumption may be hitting a speed bump.”


Chinese car sales appear to have hit a wall

Source: Chinese Association of Automobile Makers (CAAM), Organisation Internationale des Constructeurs d'Automobiles (OICA)

Policy response

President Xi and the Communist Party are not just letting events unfold around them. The Government has increased export rebates, cut corporate pension contribution requirements and trimmed taxes. The People’s Bank of China has also done its bit in the form of interest rate cuts and a decrease in the reserves that banks are required to hold, in a bid to boost lending.

China’s Government debt is relatively low at $6.5 trillion or 48% of GDP, so there looks to be plenty left in the tank when it comes to potential stimulus. But add in financial sector debt, household debt and soaring corporate debt and those figures rise to around $40 trillion or nearly 290% of GDP, which looks less comfortable.

As such, the authorities in Beijing have a tricky balancing act, as they attempt to encourage growth with cheap cash and fiscal stimulus, yet at the same time stop debt-fuelled housing and financial markets from becoming too bubbly (although in this respect it could be argued that China is no different from the US, UK, Canada, Australia or Sweden, for example).

This means growth could take on more of a stop-start pattern than previously, as stimulus boosts the economy (as per 2016), only for its effect to start to wear off (as per 2018) and the authorities to then step in again (as per 2019).

Of the three issues which held back Chinese equities last year, two now look less problematic. Oil has retreated to $60 a barrel, which helps since Beijing is a net buyer of crude. The dollar may have peaked, for now at least, using the DXY (‘Dixie’) trade-weighted index as a guide, as the Fed prepares to cut rates and the White House talks down the buck.

“Of the three issues which held back Chinese equities last year, two now look less problematic. … That still leaves the third issue – trade.”


That still leaves the third issue – trade. Financial markets are working on the principle that both Presidents Trump and Xi need a deal so one will be done. The intertwined issue of technological supremacy unfortunately means that reaching an agreement may be a lot less simple than it looks, although at least Chinese stocks are still discounting a pretty negative outcome from the negotiations with Washington. Any trade deal with the US, assuming there is one, could therefore be a step on the road to a more sustainable recovery for the Shanghai stock market.

AJ Bell Investment Director

Russ Mould’s long experience of the capital markets began in 1991 when he became a Fund Manager at a leading provider of life insurance, pensions and asset management services. In 1993 he joined a prestigious investment bank, working as an Equity Analyst covering the technology sector for 12 years. Russ eventually joined Shares magazine in November 2005 as Technology Correspondent and became Editor of the magazine in July 2008. Following the acquisition of Shares' parent company, MSM Media, by AJ Bell Group, he was appointed as AJ Bell’s Investment Director in summer 2013.

Top